One woman's search for knowledge, truth, beauty, serenity, peace, harmony and all that crap.
Names have been changed but every word is true.
Published on January 31, 2007 By Ms Mitchell In Humor
Here's the deal. I'm a white mid-westerner teaching music in urban Phoenix. In the course of a day I teach about 75 students. Of those 6 are Caucasian (one of those is my own child), 11 are African-American, two are Pacific Islanders, two are Asian and the rest are Latin American. Now, if I use short hand terms like white, black and Mexican, please don't jump all over me, I'm not trying to be politically incorrect, I'm trying to be succinct.

I have been accused of being racist because I wouldn't let a black girl use the bathroom. (I also told a white girl and a Mexican girl no.) I shrug it off.

Today however took the cake.

In my choir we are singing Hawaiian Roller Coaster Ride from Lilo and Stitch. There are some Hawaiian phrases in it. Lani is Hawaiian and she very respectfully said, " Ms. Mitchell, you're saying that wrong." Great! She has been a big help with the pronunciation. I suggested She sing the solo part for hte concert and the rest of the choir sing the echo.

Chanel, who is black, said, "That's Racist!"

The other students' responses demonstrated that they, too, found Chanel's observation ridiculous.

I calmly explained that Guadalupe was helping with pronunciatin on our Spanish song and if we do a Chinese song I wouyld be asking Melissa Cho for her help.

Chanel was not done yet. "How come we aren't singing anything African?"

Sharday, who is black, looked at her and said, "We are, you dumb beyotch, it's called Gwendete."

Chanel said, "African people don't talk all mumbo jumbo like that."

I said, "Chanel, my darling, Africans in Kenya most certainly do talk like that. Africans in Milwaukee do not."

She gave me the hand and the black girl head wag "I'm just sayin'."

To quote my darling 18 year old child of Irish, German, Swiss, Scottish, English, Cherokee and Romanian descent, "I can't make generalizations about people but one by one they are pissing me off."


Comments
on Jan 31, 2007
I can't make generalizations about people but one by one they are pissing me off.


Yep, that's about it. I don't hate any group but there sure are individuals I'd love to throttle.
on Feb 01, 2007
Ah...leave it to the minorities to put the white man down.

Heh, heh...yeah...there are always those out there that want to whip out the race card like it's a game...all we can do is sigh and move on.

Yep, that's about it. I don't hate any group but there sure are individuals I'd love to throttle.


Agreed.


~Zoo
on Feb 01, 2007

I guess it would be racist for some one to ask me to sing Les Marseilles.

Nah!  Just crazy on their part consider how I sing.

on Feb 01, 2007
"I can't make generalizations about people but one by one they are pissing me off."


In line with that very astute observation, shouldn't this have been titled "Some White People Can't Win?" Or even, "This White Person Can't Win."

Sadly, the increasing meaninglessness of race as a sociobiological construct has not been met with a corresponding decrease in frivolous and unsubstantiated accusations of racism. Like you say: shrug it off.

Still, I know how you feel. Except for being white, you know.
Buddah
(below are links explaining some of my own similar experiences.)


WWW Link

WWW Link
on Feb 01, 2007
In line with that very astute observation, shouldn't this have been titled "Some White People Can't Win?" Or even, "This White Person Can't Win."

You are absolutely right.

Being black history month and a time to honor great African Americans, I would hope that strides were made with a lot of sweat and sense of justice not entitlement. Civil rights leaders were workers and thinkers and fighters, not whiners.

(Do I dare open this can of worms?)
I feel that by Black History Month perpetuates the segregation of great black leaders from great leaders of other ethnicities.
Is there a glass ceiling on regular history, too?
on Feb 05, 2007
(Do I dare open this can of worms?)
I feel that by Black History Month perpetuates the segregation of great black leaders from great leaders of other ethnicities. Is there a glass ceiling on regular history, too?


If it does segregate, it does so only in reaction to a segregation that existed (in textbooks, laws and civil rights) until the 1960's civil rights movement. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 WWW Link finally did away with one of the last bits of structured inequality that existed for people of color for the previous 189 years of this nation's heritage.

I can understand the impatience some have with "Black History Month" because for most people aged 40 and younger, their country never had legitimate institutional racial discrimination. All they've known is that everyone is equal in America, and they forget that white males experienced a profound advantage (from 1776 to 1965) in property ownership, access to education, voting rights (among many other rights). It's almost like people are saying "come on, we've had equal rights for 40 years, what are the [insert non-white ethnicity here] talking about inequality for?"

I say it is unrealistic to expect to undo 189 years of legal, structured segregation in 42 years.

Is there a glass ceiling on history too? Hopefully not. However, I am confused by your choice of language. What is "regular history"?

Respectfully
Moskowitz
the Jewish Mexican-American Sociologist
on Feb 05, 2007
Don't misunderstand. I'm not saying that the heroes of Black History month are not laudable. On the contrary, my hope would be that these good people are remembred and their deeds discussed more often than just February. It seems that in our Attention Deficit society we need to have these things pre-packaged for us. Some of my best friends are Jewish Mexican-American sociologists
on Feb 07, 2007
No misunderstanding here - I know what you're saying. I look forward to the day when race becomes the truly arbitrary and meaningless thing that it is. Until new ideas and new behaviors have become internalized (and dare I say accepted) by the culture en masse, I guess events like "Black History Month" are a necessity.

Most people usually have friends that are either:
a. Jewish
b. Mexican-Americans
c. Sociologists
d. None of the above

Rarely are they "all of the above." I hope I'm counted among your friends.

Moskowitz the Confused